Do we Need a Public Inquiry?: Implications of Johnston’s Findings on Foreign Interference

Christian Leuprecht, Artur Wilczynski, and Thomas Juneau discuss former governor general David Johnston’s recommendation against holding a public inquiry into foreign interference in Canadian politics. 

The panel delves into the key findings highlighted in Johnston’s report, emphasizing the urgent need to address shortcomings in intelligence communication and processing. They explore alternative approaches, such as public hearings, to effectively examine and counter foreign interference. The implications of the decision not to conduct a public inquiry are thoroughly examined, taking into account the potential impact on uncovering and mitigating instances of foreign interference.

The situation leading up to David Johnson’s report involves allegations of China’s interference in past Canadian elections. To address this issue, the Prime Minister appointed an independent special rapporteur, David Johnson, to assess whether a public inquiry was necessary. However, concerns were raised about Johnson’s perceived lack of impartiality and expertise in national security matters. The report itself faced criticism for narrowly interpreting its mandate and potentially exhibiting confirmation bias.

Not conducting a public inquiry has several drawbacks, including a lack of transparency and accountability, as well as an inability to thoroughly investigate and address allegations of foreign interference. The report emphasized significant gaps in communication between security agencies and government departments, highlighting the urgent need for a more robust and effective system. Potential measures to address these gaps may involve centralizing intelligence distribution, improving information-sharing mechanisms, and investing in intelligence infrastructure.

In conclusion, there is a pressing demand for greater transparency, accountability, and the restoration of trust in Canadian democratic institutions.

Share the article :

Do you want to respond to this piece?

Submit and article. Find out how, here:


In order to personalize your user experience, CDA Institute uses strictly necessary cookies and similar technologies to operate this site. See details here.