Behind the Defence Budget Spin, Readiness Pays the Price

Dr. Stephen Saideman

One of the biggest threats facing Canadians is the blizzard of mis- and dis-information from Russia, China, the United States, and other actors. The government of Canada should fight this information war via transparency, not spin. Yet the rollout of the new budget is misleading: it makes real progress on some defence capabilities but does less than advertised in key areas. 

To be clear, allocating more money to defence is a good thing, given how much the Canadian Armed Forces (CAF) needs to acquire as it adjusts to the new reality of preparing for a potential conflict with Russia or another “peer” adversary. The submarines, planes, and other expensive procurements fill key gaps and will be valuable in the years ahead. The CAF also needs the new investment in drones, which reflects lessons learned from Ukraine’s war of defence. 

Yet much of the discussion around the defence budget is problematic, and not all of that is Canada’s fault. NATO’s 5% of GDP spending target is less a plan than a performance, staged for two audiences—coalition partners in many democracies and Donald Trump. To get European countries to spend the equivalent of 3.5% of their GDP on defence, the more enthusiastic political parties, generally right of center, had to persuade the left of center parties to go along. They did so by promising another 1.5% for infrastructure, such as helping make the trains run on time in Germany. That 1.5% is dual use: practically anything with a possible defence impact can count. Countries can therefore spend on what their domestic audiences care about and code it as defence-related. Meanwhile, the 5% headline also was meant to soothe Trump’s temper.

In a recent e-mail circulated by the Minister of National defence’s office to the defence and security community, the government emphasized “more than $700 billion in combined core and broader defence- and security-related expenditures over five years”. The problem is that almost half of that figure is “defence-related” spending, and it may not reflect any real new money.  The figures show Canada going from nothing in this category to $48.7 billion in a single year. That looks mostly like existing expenses is being re-coded as “defence- and security-related”. It strains credulity to believe that this or any Canadian government could spend $50 billion in new money in a single year. That $48.7 billion then grows modestly each year, likely just enough to cover inflation. In other words, a large share of the “new” money is not new. 

The second way this new budget is less than it seems is that it asks the military to move money around to fund the expanded commitment to the mission in Latvia, Operation Reassurance. This is a very important mission. It helps deter Russian aggression, it shows Europeans that Canada is making a big and real commitment to European defence, and it occupies nearly all of the Canadian Army’s efforts. Spending $7 billion more as the mission grows from 2,200 to 2,600 personnel makes sense, though both figures overstate the deployment, since they include Canada-based troops sent over occasionally for exercises. The problem is that the money is coming out of resources the military has already been allocated.  This means a $7 billion cut somewhere. Given the focus on new equipment and much-deserved raises, the cut will probably fall on operations, training, and maintenance. In other words, there will be less money to get and keep the CAF ready to fight. These items are not glamorous, but they are essential for making the military as sharp and as effective as possible. Combined with the 10% cut DND/CAF faces along with other government agencies, this means the new budget is not quite the bonanza that it appears to be.

One last item: new spending on intelligence, which experts say is badly needed now that the United States has become a less reliable supplier, will be counted not as “defence- and security-related” funding but as “core defence” funding. Once again, the military is not getting as much new money as it might seem.

There will be more spending, and there will be many announcements. But the media and the public should keep asking: how much of it is new money, and how much of the new money goes directly to readiness? Will there be new money for spare parts so that our planes can fly, our ships can sail, and our vehicles can drive? Will there be new money for exercises and other training? Or will there be less?

This announcement and the existing defence strategy have other problems, such as the claim that the Arctic faces great threats and that this money is aimed at them. But first, the math needs to be clearer. A war of narratives is best fought with a good story, and especially with a true one.  In a time of so much misinformation, the government of Canada should be clear about what its new budget will actually pay for.

Dr. Stephen Saideman holds the Paterson Chair in International Affairs at Carleton University’s Norman Paterson School of International Affairs, where he also directs the Canadian Defence and Security Network and co-hosts the Battle Rhythm podcast. He has written five books on ethnic conflict, alliances and civil-military relations, including the award-winning Overseen or Overlooked: Legislators, Armed Forces, and Democratic Accountability.

The views expressed in this op-ed are the author’s own and do not necessarily represent those of the Institute or its staff.

Photo: Lars Hagberg / Office of the Prime Minister of Canada

Share the article :

Do you want to respond to this piece?

Submit and article. Find out how, here:

Cookies

In order to personalize your user experience, CDA Institute uses strictly necessary cookies and similar technologies to operate this site. See details here.